Opinion: How the media can learn from the Last Guardian reporting fiasco
Saturday was a bad night for the gaming media, with a false Last Guardian rumor briefly taking the internet by storm. It's also a night that everyone in the media should back at and take a moment to learn from the many mistakes made.
Saturday, the media was all-too-quick to declare this game cancelled
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are solely of the author and may not necessarily reflect the views of Shacknews and its staff.
-
Ozzie Mejia posted a new article, Opinion: How the media can learn from the Last Guardian reporting fiasco.
Saturday was a bad night for the gaming media, with a false Last Guardian rumor briefly taking the internet by storm. It's also a night that everyone in the media should back at and take a moment to learn from the many mistakes made.-
-
And on top of that, don't take word from one guy that works for Sony Russia as "official". No offense to Russia, but I suspect they don't hold a very big or important Sony office. If it's not coming straight from Sony Japan, or maybe US/UK, I wouldn't trust it any more than some random internet dude.
-
-
"There's a very real reason why a sector of gamers, such as a growing number of NeoGAF posters, inherently distrust the gaming media."
Maybe it's because things like this have been happened for a while. It's not just NeoGAF, it's any gamer who's old enough to remember when 'gaming journalism' was actually reputable. Most gaming sites are nothing but clickbait pits, platforms for social justice pandering, or just extensions of publishers' marketing departments. The internet allows anyone with a half-passing interest in games and a competent handle on the English language to hop up on their soapbox and say what they want, and that's done nothing but hurt the industry. It really makes my brain hurt when I think about all of the now-shuttered gaming magazines that have been replaced by people more interested in ad revenue than reporting the facts.
I've always held Shacknews in high regard because it's always just been about the news, without the sensationalism of Kotaku and the SJW mindset of Polygon. I really think it's one of the last few good gaming news sites out there, and I'd like it to stay that way.
Ozzie, if you really believe that we as readers have the right to keep the gaming media honest, keep writing pieces like this. Keep putting the spotlight on the ineptitude of so-called gaming journalists. Keep it out there that we could do better, and that we deserve better.-
Our goal is to be the best gaming site we can be. Even if we have a fluff piece here and there, it's ultimately for the purpose of being enthusiasts. We love games and we want to show how much we love games. But yes, as we've shown in past weeks, if something doesn't work with our audience, we aren't afraid to scrap it.
Just know that even if an occasional fluff piece does pop up on this site, it will never be at the expense of our regular coverage.-
I think there is a good balance right now. I'm human, I like goofy fluff pieces, but I have been reading most of the long form articles around here lately too. I'm a big fan of the throw everything at the wall and see what sticks way you guys have been running these past few weeks. I have noticed myself visiting other sites less (even Giant Bomb O8) and watching the Shack's videos and reading their articles.
-
-
Honestly I think the only the only reason why this is such a big deal is because it is so believable, and is kinda just what everyone has been waiting and anticipating to hear. The "development" of the game has been dragged on so long that we all just wonder what, even before the stories, has happened to to the game, is it still alive? is it dead?.
I highly doubt the game has been in constant development, so there is also an onus on Sony for not letting people know that "hey we may have possibly, kinda, sorta put the game on hold until we know what direction it is goign in"
-