2011 Game of the Year - The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
Shacknews is proud to announce that our 2011 Game of the Year is The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, from developer CD Projekt RED. Read why we picked it, here!
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings may be draped in the cloak of a brutal fantasy world filled with monsters and magic, but it offers an interesting reflection of real-world problems. It's a political drama where those in command are governed by fear and uncertainty. It shines light on racism and sexism in ways that shows developer CD Projekt RED is unafraid to push narrative boundaries beyond most games in its class.
Based on the book series from Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski, The Witcher 2 goes worlds beyond the 2007 original title in almost every conceivable way (though there is some contention with the game's ending). Combat is completely overhauled--and after a few balance tweaks soon after release, it's satisfying to the point of perfection. The game can be unapologetic in its command for your attention and skill, pushing aside a generation of games marketed to the era of players raised by handholding execution.
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings was perhaps a game many have missed due to its demanding requirements, but it was (and remains) an adventure of epic scale and scope. It is one of the few games that genuinely offers players a choice. What you do matters, offering players a diverging path that shelves an entire section of the game reserved for choosing another path.
Beyond the joy of slaying monsters and uncovering a major conspiracy as Geralt of Rivia, The Witcher 2 is gorgeous. If your machine can handle it, The Witcher 2 may be the most breathtaking adventure we've ever experienced.
Much like any game--even those we regard as classics--The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings has a few missteps; though many of its "bugs" have long since been squashed by the game's developer.
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings isn't vast in the same way that Skyrim is. It is often linear in its overall story, though choices made along the way are important to the tale. Linearity is only troublesome if a game's vision is as confined as its environments are and The Witcher 2 suffers from no such flaw. It is focused. It's a wonderful game that you must play (either now on PC or this upcoming May when it arrives on Xbox 360). For these reasons and more, The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings has proudly been voted as the Shacknews.com 2011 Game of the Year.
The Shacknews 2011 Game of the Year awards are based on a weighted scoring system between all staff writers and editors [here's how it works!]. Last week we revealed our "Honorable Mentions," which include the titles that did not quite make our overall 'Top Five Games of the Year.' Today is our final award, the 'Shacknews 2011 Game of the Year' award.
-
Shack Staff posted a new article, 2011 Game of the Year - The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings.
Shacknews is proud to announce that our 2011 Game of the Year is The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, from developer CD Projekt RED. Read why we picked it, here!-
-
-
-
-
I love Dark Souls and it was probably my GOTY too, but you do realize that this complaint:
"The game does a terrible job of helping you learn the combat and magic system"
can be applied to any number of things in either of the Souls games, right? They are not exactly known for teaching the player very well.
That said, I haven't even played either Witcher so ::shrug::
-
-
-
-
DA:O was indeed awesome, but nowhere as immersive, deep, and as TW2. That game's story goes beyond the "save the world" syndrome that most RPG's suffer from.
It really is an original story that is really complex.
In TW2 you get the feeling that there is a world outside of Geralt and he just got stuck in the entire ordeal.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Yeah definitely play it. The intro starts out kind of slow, but if you love mature storylines, lore, and cool characters, its awesome. Just make sure to pay attention to the quest updates at the bottom of the screen, they contain information that your quest log doesn't.
The Witcher is one of my favorite games and one of the best RPGs I've played. It doesn't hold your hand though, so just anticipate some times where you think you are stuck, but you really aren't.-
-
-
-
Yeah I had the same issue when I originally started playing. Then it got to the point where I had everything I could maxed and had bronze talent points just stacking up, so I just started taking random stuff like Geralt takes longer to get drunk, and fist fighting etc etc lol.
Anything that makes Geralt a better sword fighter, or more life, or resistances is what I would focus on first, but its not so strict that you will turn him into a pushover.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
This. I put probably 10 hours in to The Witcher 2 and just lost interest. The thing is I really like the first one, and am a fan of the character, and a fan of RPGs in general.
Skyrim I've easily put 100 hours in before I burnt out, but I'm planning on going back and playing more to finish more quests later.
So I can't say I agree with it being game of the year.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Prepare to die, and the abilities in the second one are very different depending on what talent tree you go with. So its hard to say which ones are the best, since its so much more balanced than the first one, where Igni reigned supreme.
General tips, don't pick up every crafting material you find, just remember the general area, the game gives you tons of materials, so no need to packrat.
Combat is difficult so make sure you prep with potions, otherwise more hot death. And don't bang anyone with family around, you see everything but Geralts 3rd sword. -
-
Play on Hard mode for more enjoyment out of combat. Learn to crowd control from the very start of the game, and do hit-and-runs to pick off weaker guys around the edge of the fight.
It's possible to spread your points out to get BOTH the magic and sword finishers at the same time, and they both activate at once on the same bar. I did it on one game.
Overall I get as much Vigor as possible from all the talents that add it. Quen is gamebreaking, the best spell by far. Igni is pretty good. I didn't use the other 2. For combat skills, most are passive bonuses so take your pick to get up to the finisher.
-
-
-
-
-
Lol, it's funny how many people are butthurt, or more baffling, actually surprised that Skyrim placed below the Witcher 2. I fail to understand why everyone treats that average game like the second coming.
Generic sandbox fantasy game that was overrated as all shit places below an actually good game? Unheard of! -
-
-
Thanks for sticking with us (most of you) through this GOTY reveal. We're glad to have ended up surprising you. That obviously wasn't the intention, but it just worked out.
Also, I should point out that all five of the top five games ended up being games that were also available on PC--and in many cases, offered the best experience (or in The Witcher 2's case, the only experience) on the PC.
Another thing that just ended up working out, but we're happy it ended up meshing with the roots of this community.
Also, unless it wasn't clear--I wrote The Witcher 2 GOTY post. -
-
-
Man, what a great year for gaming! Deus Ex: HR was a great return to form. Skyrim improved on Oblivion in so many ways I can''t even count them. Batman: AC I've put more hours into than any action game ever. Portal 2 was one of the best and most unique co-op experiences I've had. I've only played enough of The Witcher 2 to know that I like it even more than the first one in every way. All these games are fabulous, and only one of them would be in my top five games of the year!
On a side note, I've spent more money on gaming this year than all other years combined. -
-
This is absolute crap and you should be ashamed of yourselves. The PC version of Monday Night Combat came out this year and should have been the clear choice, but nobody's memory in the gaming press seems to go back that far. I am literally outraged at your entire GotY process if it can allow a travesty such as this to happen.
-
Summarized 2011 Shacknews GOTY Awards
GOTY: Witcher 2
Runners-up:
1st: Portal 2
2nd: Batman: Arkham City
3rd: Skyrim
4th: Deus Ex: Human Revolution
Honorable Mentions:
Bastion
Super Mario 3D Land
Zelda: Skyward Sword
Saints Row the Third
LittleBigPlanet 2
Article with Similar roll-up: http://www.shacknews.com/article/71890/shacknews-best-of-2011-awards
Staff Picks:
Garnett: Shadows of the Damned, Forza 4, FIFA 12, LotR: War in the North
Steve: Minecraft, Pushmo, Mortal Kombat, Dead Space 2, Iron Brigade (Trenched), Bulletstorm
Alice: Bulletstorm, Child of Eden, Johann Sebastian Joust
Ozzie: Infamous 2, Mortal Kombat, LA Noire, Driver: San Francisco, Serious Sam: Double D
Jeff: Warhammer 40k: Space Marine, To the Moon, Space Pirates and Zombies
Andrew: ICO & SotC Collection, Gears of War 3, Rayman Origins, LA Noire, Dance Central 2, Outland, Bulletstorm
Xav: Crysis 2, DC Universe Online, Dead Space 2, Mortal Kombat, Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet, Rayman Origins, Minecraft, Infinity Blade 2, Dark Souls-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
I can't really agree with your first sentence. There are plenty of nifty changes and iterative improvements that actually give it a really fresh feel.
It's more of the same in some ways but it's also mixed with interesting new stuff that really pushes the game's appeal and quality into the stratosphere, imho.
I find myself agreeing with .ka boom.zZz (most annoying name to spell, ever) in being disappointed at Alice's game likes but we're all different and have different tastes, too. It does strike me as odd that she's claimed to be such a diehard PC gaming fan only to miss the big picture entirely on what is probably one of the best PC-specific games to be released in a few years. :(
However, I don't agree with the somewhat harsh tone Ka'Boom uses in his post, either.
-
-
-
-
I am so bored of the type of FPS Battlefield 3 is. It holds no interest for me anymore. Battlefield 3 is good One of Those FPSs, no doubt, but no, not for me. You like it, and that's great--you're hardly alone in that--but I don't.
My honourable mentions are my "Hey, these things were interesting too!" I listed Bulletstorm because it was fun with some novel ideas, and I was so surprised that I liked it. People saw me groan and grumble about Bulletstorm in the run-up to its launch, based on the marketing and that boring demo, and I wanted to share how wrong I'd been. -
-
-
-
-
-
-
BF3 is a lot of fun but I think it has a lot of problems too, and there were a lot of better games this year. Personally it would probably fall in my top 5 (probably closer to the bottom of that) but I can definitely see other people not being blown away by it. It didn't do anything particularly noteworthy over previous entries in the series.
-
-
how so? I find BF3 MP is vastly improved. the game changes as you play. the destructibility and vehicles are just incredibly amazing. the gun variety is awesome, loadouts are great, and there's always really good combat.
where you had stalemates before, BF3 is very dynamic. the only real drawback is the 24/7 metro conquest maps... but I guess on ANY game that has progression,people will want a way to farm XP or gold or valor or whatever.
it's just so awesome to be a ground pounder and have some ace pilot make a critical strafe run, or some other squad laser lock and javelin kill an enemy tank holding a street.... or just have some motherfucker bring down an entire building, changing the map landscape for the rest of that map's playtime.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
I'm not really arguing, I see where you're coming from. ;)
However, choosing to package in BF3's single-player into one's overall opinion is like considering "Saints Row 3's" Whored Mode as 1/2 the game. I look at both as bonus content. Had BF3 only released the multiplayer component, are you saying it would be different? -
-
-
-
-
imo when it comes down to it it is just what engaged you the most. BF3 multiplayer is excellent, great sound, great graphics, fun gameplay. but it just doesn't grab you the same way a game like the witcher 2 can. i'm going to stop here because I just realized how dumb it is to compare a modern combat FPS to a 3rd person fantasy rpg
-
-
-
The staff of this site are just disconnected from the chatty folks. They aren't us, they aren't like us anymore.
They also touch a lot more games than most of us. We have to pick and choose the games we want to play with the dollars we want to spend in advance. Sometimes our judgement of a game is colored by the money we spent. I know I only bought a handful of games at launch this year, and for the most part I loved them despite their flaws because I want my $60 worth from each one.
But this really this is writers vs gamers.
-
-
I can see why people get butthurt over these lists, when's the last time THE INTERNET held hands in a unified rainbow-circle of agreement? Every gaming site do these lists and personally, I don't care what "wins" any awards but I always pay attention to what is nominated - "the field". That way, I know that if I choose to play ANY of the games under consideration, I have a pretty big chance of liking it - especially if it's a genre that I enjoy. The absence of BF3 from that ENTIRE list is peculiar. I believe each of the Staff members picks are ~genuine but the exclusion of BF3 from all SEVEN lists just raises a red flag on objectivity to me. Since Shacknews/Gamefly is a non-niche, "general" gaming site, they should seriously consider hiring an editor that really plays First Person Shooters.
-
-
It should have been in your top 10, especially since I remember Shacknews being a big quake news coverage site back in the day. Multi-player is a huge and extremely important aspect of gaming or have you guys forgotten? To even judge a game like battlefield 3 on its single player is a joke, the single player was obviously just in there as a way to show off the tech and for a bit of fun. Its like judging the Quake series on its single player merits... just silly! : /
-
-
-
-
I'm thrilled to see Witcher 2 receive this award, but man, is this a lame article. The text is almost completely lacking any texture, any nuance, any EXAMPLES other than "uncovering a major conspiracy as Geralt of Rivia," which is grammatically incorrect. I know the game was reviewed already, but you'd think Shacknews would want to paint an evocative picture of its GOTY, a rich description that would make readers who haven't played the game want to jump in. These substanceless paragraphs utterly fail to do that. Every claim should have some detail, some piece of evidence, to give it heft. Instead the article tells us the game is great, but sure doesn't show us. I guess the problem is this: great games deserve great writing.
-
Read the review for more details about the game: http://www.shacknews.com/article/68543/witcher-2-assassins-kings-review
-
-
All you fake Witcher 2 lovers can get out. http://www.shacknews.com/chatty?id=27374802
-
Awesome, glad to see it on top. Also my GOTY, no question. Yeah, I played Skyrim for 120 hours, but I put a good 70 into The Witcher 2 across my 3 playthroughs, and I absolutely loved every second.
Other games with moral choices given to the player really need to look closely at this game. It's amazing making a choice that's not even close to being black and white that ALSO affects the story and the world in potentially profound ways. I hate moral choices in most games because it's basically "Do you want to be a totally nice guy or a complete asshat?" -
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRSrJLBgLLM
Now this is going to be in my head for days....
-
-
-
-
I don't think the Elder Scrolls games have ever been about being difficult or a challenge. Maybe in the beginning, but the point of the game is the story and, essentially, becoming something of a god by the end.
But I think that's the difference between MP and SP games. I think people generally play SP games for the story and immersion and MP games are more for the challenge. -
-
-
-
-
-
-
I'd still like to know: http://www.shacknews.com/chatty?id=27503171
-
-
-
-
"Clearly the best game to come out of 2011".
I haven't even bothered to check, but how many other outlets gave this their top award? Your statement is subjective.
In a field of so many stellar games this year with much more brand recognition and exposure, it is not the likely pick.
That doesn't make it wrong, but it does make it odd.
Again this is my opinion. Notice how I didn't say your opinion was wrong?
-
-
-
-
-
I can't disagree with The Witcher 2 as GOTY, in fact kudos for going with it. I thoroughly enjoyed Witcher 2, it was leagues above Dragon Age 2, and almost every other RPG that came out this year. Having said all that, Skyrim still gets my GOTY, but Witcher 2 made my top 5 (I probably play a hundred+ games a year).
-
-
-
Good pick!
I AM, however, disappointed that they missed the boat somehow (bizarrely) on BF3's amazing-ness. It sounds like (from Xav's comments above) that they dinged it too hard for the so-so Single-player. Imho, that's sort of like missing the forest for the trees, unfortunately.
BF3 is easily one of the best PC-specific games to come out in recent years. It should probably been somewhere in the runner-up list, at the very least. Sigh. :(