As promised from yesterday, here is a rundown of some of the more thoughtful reviews by readers of RocketArena3 (download it here). It seems pretty positive but the general themes seem to be scoreboard is stinky, lack of stats, and a few people seem convinced that strafe jumping is messed up. This is more than likely due to the use of DLLs. Its fairly common knowledge among the more advanced players that DLLs have been known to futz with the physics. (Havent tried it much myself to see). Well, on with the reviews:
Reviews from: notsoleet (& pt 2) , anon@uswest , anon@albacom , Mr.Mojo , than , MrShmoo , Polish Sausage , [Vi]Archer , mc-fine , KingBishop , wageslave , skid , Dopeman , b00la , Geoff! , Pimpstick , Moebius , dra. , Julios , and Thresher
Also, you can see a bunch of responses made by crt (the programmer) right here.
Steve Gibson is the cofounder of Shacknews.com. Originally known as sCary's Quakeholio back in 1996, Steve is now President of Gearbox Publishing after selling Shacknews to GameFly in 2009.